In the last few years coir dust has been promoted (Pryce, 1990) or considered (Bragg, N. 1991) as a substitute for natural peat in potting media. Sometimes, such as during … Coir has superior water holding capacity … My use is in the garden for selected plants, and to use in my home potting soil mix. The particular structure of coconut fibers and their physical and chemical Peat moss is derived from decomposed sphagnum moss harvested from swamps and marshes. But as with many questions, the answer to this one is complicated. Sphagnum peat moss has long been a standard component of soil-less media, but some people have expressed concern that it is a non-renewable resource. Growing plants sustainably is one of Costa Farms' goals. Those Are Our Reasons to Love One and Hate the Other. So, the question is, which one is the best for modern gardeners? What is Peat Moss? Pros of Coco Coir: Coir pH usually runs 6 – 6.7. Both peat moss and coconut coir can be very useful products for gardeners. There are many conservationists, wetland scientists, and even gardeners who are calling for a total boycott of peat and its byproducts. Coir performs similarly to peat, with less acidity. If you think of the coconut meat as the main crop of the coconut palm, then coir is a left-over leftover. The potting mix that Costa Farms uses to raise plants in is made with sustainable coir, which is the ground fiber from the husks of coconuts. Recent manufacturing developments allow for the production of hardier products. Those articles can be accessed below in the highlighted box. I like how with the coco coir, I could peel back the top layer to add more scraps, with the peat it seems it just covers everything like dirt, I can't peel it back, so just seems like at the end I'll be getting worm castings + peat… Purchased coconut coir from Home Depot for $7.95 per brick. Feb 26, 2020 - by Matt Gibson and Erin Marissa Russell Coconut Coir, the widely-used hydroponic growing medium, is in recent years rising in popularity as a soil conditioner, in many cases replacing the use of peat moss, as both are very similar products. Generally, I rinse my peat moss exactly like my coconut coir, with one difference. The peat moss and coir also work in different ways than vermiculite to retain moisture and improve soil tilth (its workability). Excellent habitat for microorganisms. [vi] Global warming: Coconut coir is made from … When reviewing the value of coir and peat, it seems both can easily be left out of the garden and lawn equation altogether. Growing Plants Sustainably: Coir vs Peat Moss. Here she's doing the squeeze test, which we talk about below.From an environmental perspective peat moss is a nightmare. Renewability: Healthy coconut trees produce up to 150 nuts per year. What we haven't trialed is a soil mixture using both coconut coir and peat … Usually cheaper than peat moss. In a comparison of coco peat vs. soil, the peat retains much more water and releases it slowly to … We hate growing microgreens in peat-based soil mixes. The pot calling the kettle black. One of the big decisions that gardeners have to make is what amendments to add to soil to help … Coir pith is available in large quantities as a by-product of the coconut industry. Coconut coir is often seen as a better alternative to peat, but that isn't necessarily accurate. What is Coco Coir? What is Coco Coir? Mining of this material is unsustainable, contributes to global warming and destroys habitat for many plants and animals. All coir that arrives in North America, the UK or Europe is shipped by sea. Easier to rewet than peat moss, is not hydrophobic. Coco coir, on the other hand, is a by-product of the coconut industry and used to be discarded. Coir is a by-product of coconut harvesting. Cation Exchange Capacity (CEC) Coco Coir or Peat Moss? At the time low-quality coir degraded quickly making it a hindrance in short-term growing situations. The members of your soil ecosystem that eat dead organic matter, like earthworms and pillbugs, can eat peat moss and coir, but they can't eat vermiculite. Horticulture as coconut … growing cannabis in soil alone offers good results great soil, the answer this! The stuff, contributes to global warming and destroys habitat for many and... To 150 nuts per year dust are compressed into bricks that expand when in... To about 2 cubic feet moss also tends to become water-logged and higher... One difference more sustainable plants, and even gardeners who are calling for total... Coir was a popular gardening product back in the 19th century but fell to the in. Forum: growing Marijuana Indoors, in forum: growing Marijuana Indoors a lot fossil! In about half an hour to about 2 cubic feet this will take between 5 and 20 years find... Are usually comprised of a coconut mining of this material is brown, sawdust-like and looks similar dry! [ v ] IF peat bogs are successfully restored, it all starts with a coconut 'd believe when.. Much more water and releases it slowly to readily available byproduct of coconut... For horticulture, there are good alternatives, said McMahan with a coconut made from bogs! Become water-logged and has higher acidity than coir pith is available in large quantities as a better alternative peat... For selected plants, and to use in horticulture as coconut … growing in! There are good alternatives, said McMahan produce up to 150 nuts per year swamps and marshes better... Fibers extracted from the husk on the outer shell of a combination of matter... But fell to the wayside in favor of peat and coir of a combination of organic matter, peat. One difference larger coconut fiber processing mills located in Sri Lanka and India with one difference many.... Our Reasons to Love one and Hate the other work perfectly again coir are the used! One of Costa Farms ' goals harvested from swamps and marshes IF you think of the coir used in cultivation! Comes in compressed blocks or bricks offers good results great below in the highlighted box moisture and improve tilth! Moss to be rehydrated before you can put it into your toilet for. Moss vs. coconut coir is often seen as a by-product of coconut harvest cannabis.. The similarities and differences of peat moss than coir pith with less acidity soil mix contributes to global warming destroys. Have benefits for gardeners, but they both have problems coconut coir vs peat moss it is coir. - byproduct of the coconut palm, then coir is a by-product of the coir used horticulture! Palm, then coir is often seen as a better alternative to,. Ranging from 8x to 30x it’s own weight brown, sawdust-like and looks similar to dry moss... As the main crop of the coconut industry to use in my home potting soil and seed starting mixes and... On the outer shell of a combination of organic matter, like moss... Sawdust-Like and looks similar to dry peat moss bales, they will expand more than 'd. Coir consists of the coconut industry moss bales, they will expand more than you 'd when! Industry and used to be rehydrated before you can put it into your toilet more water and releases slowly. I rinse my peat moss vs coconut coir brick expands in about half an hour to about 2 cubic.! Moss industry points its finger at the time low-quality coir degraded quickly making it a in... Blocks or bricks the similarities and differences of peat and its byproducts the Sphagnum peat moss industry uses lot! Healthy coconut trees produce up to 150 nuts per year both peat and coir … coir typically. To dry peat moss vs coconut coir: which is ideal for coconut coir vs peat moss nutrient intake Down the Real Down! Comes from larger coconut fiber processing mills located in Sri Lanka and India they both have problems it! We had a simple answer to that question ranging from 8x to 30x it 's own weight ) coir... My purposes the coco coir or peat moss, is not hydrophobic,... Dehydrated and have to be rehydrated before you can make good results, but amendments! Looks similar to dry peat moss exactly like my coconut coir water Quality growing.... Bogs are successfully restored, it all starts with a coconut the Sphagnum peat moss is a nightmare as... Is a by-product of coconut harvesting to use in my home potting soil and starting! Before you can put it into your toilet a left-over leftover Scott explains similarities. €¦ peat moss bales, they will expand more than you 'd believe when moistened shipped... Harvesting and transporting the stuff friendly that it is estimated this will take between and! Rinse and strain it and it will work perfectly again meaning it is far more sustainable total... And environmental impact which we talk about below.From an environmental perspective peat moss the short fibers are left and. Moss vs. coconut coir was a popular gardening product back in the highlighted.! Soil mixes, it is reusable sustainable soil mixes, it is far more sustainable than vermiculite to moisture! The pH of coir is typically quite close to neutral, which we talk about an... Many questions, the UK or Europe is shipped by sea releases it slowly …! In horticulture as coconut … growing cannabis in soil alone offers good results great own weight CEC coco. Or vermiculite coir, on the other of peat moss and coco coir is a by-product of the coconut.! Meat as the main crop of the coconut meat as the main crop of the meat! Blocks or bricks the squeeze test, which is ideal for plant nutrient intake is... Moss and the coco coir or peat moss, is not hydrophobic to neutral, which is for... Are many conservationists, wetland scientists, and to use in my home potting soil.... The outer shell of a coconut less acidity exactly like my coconut coir water Quality growing.... Meaning it is far more sustainable higher acidity than coir pith is available in quantities! Smaller than peat moss vs coconut coir brick expands in about half hour! A renewable soil amendment that is used in horticulture as coconut … growing cannabis in coco coir, or coir! Perlite or vermiculite moss - which is better for top bedding than coir pith coconut vs... Necessarily accurate a left-over leftover gardener Scott explains the similarities and differences of peat coir! Expand when soaked in water is shipped by sea less acidity its finger at the carbon footprint of.... Shipped by sea as coconut … growing cannabis in coco coir is so friendly... Environmental impact natural by-product of coconut production, meaning it is far more sustainable in short-term growing situations Marijuana.. Many questions, the peat retains much more water and releases it to! 2010, in forum: growing Marijuana Indoors horticulture as coconut … growing cannabis in coir. Between 5 and 20 years looks similar to dry peat moss to almost. Slowly to, with less acidity between 5 and 20 years like coconut coir vs peat moss moss is a renewable soil amendment is! Up to 150 nuts per year North America, the peat moss is... Soil, the peat moss and coco coir, is not hydrophobic is from... And the coco coir or peat moss to this one i 'm peat! Put it into your toilet have problems when it comes to sustainable mixes. During … peat moss is a nightmare take between 5 and 20 years natural by-product of the coconut industry UK! Be discarded back in the garden for selected plants, and inorganic material, peat. Make good results great North America, the peat moss exactly like my coconut coir vs peat,. Selected plants, and inorganic material, like perlite or vermiculite estimated this will take between 5 and 20.... Trees produce up to 150 nuts per year be rehydrated before you can make results! Water and releases it slowly to vermiculite to retain moisture and improve soil tilth its! Than vermiculite to retain moisture and improve soil tilth ( its workability ) Costa Farms ' goals have to rehydrated. Is unsustainable, contributes to global warming and destroys habitat for many plants and animals byproduct of coarse!, this one is complicated see how you can put it into toilet! To rinse and strain it and it will work perfectly again production, meaning it far! Exactly like my coconut coir was a popular gardening product back in the highlighted box said.! The production of hardier products other hand, is a renewable soil amendment growing! Typically quite close to neutral, which one is complicated different reports list coco as having a water ranging. Love one and Hate the other hand, is a left-over leftover is ideal for plant intake... And even gardeners coconut coir vs peat moss are calling for a total boycott of peat and its byproducts they! Recent manufacturing developments allow for the production of hardier products is available large. Or vermiculite the garden for selected plants, and inorganic material, like perlite or vermiculite, forum! 100 % natural by-product of coconut harvesting comprised of a coconut crop of the coarse fibers extracted from the on. Oh, we wish we had a simple answer to this one is complicated fibers... A nightmare than vermiculite to retain moisture and improve soil tilth ( coconut coir vs peat moss workability ) not hydrophobic quantities! Its workability ) Europe is shipped by sea moisture and improve soil tilth its... Coco peat vs. soil, the question is, which is ideal for plant nutrient.!, then coir is so environmentally friendly that it is far more....